New Mandala

New perspectives on mainland Southeast Asia

New Mandala random header image

I’m just a soul whose intentions are good …

January 28th, 2010 by Andrew Walker · 20 Comments

[On my return from a well-earned rest in Tasmania, I found the following in my inbox.]

“I Built My Life”

by Dr. Thaksin Shinawatra
(Prime Minister of Thailand, 2001-2006)

Chapter 1 (Tuesday, January 26, 2010)

A lot of my self-appointed enemies are now working so hard in branding me a figure of corruption. Thai media in the likes of The Nation, The Manager Group, Naewna, Thaipost. All of them are busily doing “negative campaign” hoping to influence the court soon to judge me and my family of the seized 76,000 million Baht, which is the fruit of my life’s work. Influencing the court is indeed a violation of the court’s jurisdiction. But they still do. That is precisely why I must ask you to allow me to use a portion of this show to tell you of my life struggle, as some people, especially those of the new generations, do not know what is true and what is pure fiction. They must know that I and my family have been wealthy long before our entrance to politics, and politics have never been a tool or a source of our wealth.

Such seizure, deemed “robbery” by some, is against all principles of ethics and morality. These people are in total lack of life principle. I may dislike someone intensely, but I have never gone after the person beyond these principles. Look what happens in the US. The government is financing in great amount the struggling financial and insurance corporations. One must look at the bright and gloomy sides to understand the overall. Have I been bad from day one, when I assumed Thailand’s premiership, to the very last? My premiership has absolutely nothing to claim credits for, hasn’t it? Our loan to Myanmar, to cite just one such accusation, is portrayed as my financing them so they could buy products sold to them by my family companies. How about those concessions they granted to PTT (Thailand’s Petroleum) along the years? Don’t they count as a merit to obtain such loan?

This is my way of explaining to all of you, the fair-minded international citizens, of the truth betrayed nowadays in Thailand. If you like it, I will consider expanding the show into 2 hours. It is not my self-advertising. Rather my life anecdotes. I will tell all. My colorful fights in my working life. Hope it help you in your own tough times right now.

I was born in the country, San Kampang, Chiangmai, away from what you would call an urban life. The nearest town was 13 kilometres away, with big trees on the 2 long road sides. My father had a motorcycle and struggled to make ends meet. At the age of 3-4, I started my memories of his and my mother’s hard works. He opened a small, country-style coffee corner. My mom woke up first, along with me, and boiled the water for dad. He would come down and start selling. By that time, my mom went to the open market for her business of selling clothes. Before she arrived, I would get there with a helper of hers. I was a little one so I sat in the frontal part of a wooden cart we used for clothes. I would just sit there, watching out for our products, till my mom showed up. I went back home and helped cleaning coffee glasses. Sometimes I did it on the stretch of my toes, as I was so small. This became my routine before going out to school.

There was no such thing as kindergarten at the time. However, there was a volunteer at the Rongtham Temple by the name of “Kru Kwai” (Teacher Buffalo) from Uttaradit. She was not highly-educated, but she was one superb teacher. Parents paid her 80 Baht per month to teach their children. I was a student of hers. She would give us an individual session. Interested students got a longer session. From basic Thai language to Mathematics. Kru Kwai was an excellent Math teacher. I learned plus, minus, times, divided. Pretty advanced for a child that age. I believe Kru Kwai was responsible for my progressive and interactive thinking process, which benefits me in later years.

My family helped here, too. Senior family members always challenged me, teasingly, to do Math. They would keep asking my all those Math puzzles until I was cornered. Math helps you think.

When I was in Grade 3, my dad changed from a coffee shop business to farming. My granny gave him a piece of land and he turned it into a fruit field. I learned a lot here. Dad was not highly-educated, but he was fond of new technologies. He went to Thammasat, which was then an open university much like Ramkanheang today. I remember that our little coffee shop had a refrigerator. It was oil-generated. The only one in that area. The fridge attracted a lot of people. We sold soda water and my mom’s frozen foodstuffs. I helped them selling “Wanyen” or an ice stick with a bit of sweet syrup, one “Slung” (one cent) a piece. Same as lottery results. One Slung a sheet also. My dad grew oranges and bananas. I sold banana leaves (people used them as today’s plastic bags) and flowers attached on banana’s trunk. Money from that was used to buy food back home. I grew up all my life like this, making a living with hard works.

At the time I enrolled at Montford, which was and is a famous school. I was forced to repeat Grade 3 because the first 2 Shinawatra boys’ academic performance was so poor they thought the third one must be as bad.

My very first visit to Bangkok was when I was in Grade 4. A cousin bet me to obtain 80% or over on my academic report. The reward was to take me to Bangkok. I got 84%. I traveled to Bangkok with my granny and we stayed for 4 days. On the way, we stopped at Kao Samroyyod (the Mountain of 300 Peaks), where my now well-publicized photograph among pineapples was taken. It was owned by my dad’s friend, who sold him tractors for our farm. With 400 Baht given by my granny, so much at the time, I bought some toys back home. One of them was roller-skate shoes, the wheel kind. We the kids played them at night when the road was empty. I played with these toys. I got into sports of every kind. We played all seasons, even when it rained.

Dad changed his work again. He was now a compradore of the Nakorn Luang Thai Bank. A compradore at the time screened loans giving out to the applicants. Eventually, he took over some troubled businesses from his clients. I remembered one called “Charoenchai”, a Honda motorcycle agent. I went everywhere to collect monthly payments from our clients, 100 Baht per month a piece. My life had always been close to people’s real life. I understand them well. My study was also prospering. I didn’t spend so much time reading my textbooks. But I did my homework, and that helped me understand it even better. Dad got involved in several businesses this way. Then he was cheated by business partners. The family fortune started sinking. It was the beginning of our rough time. One of my dad’s helpers asked me to stop school and came to work full-time to revive the business. I told him no. “Money and properties can be earned back. But without knowledge, we will be lost”. Those were my words to him.

I attended the national military cadet school at the time, which took 2 years. Before getting accepted, I wasted the first year because of a health result. They declared I had a spot in my lung. It was later proven a shadow of a rip or bone. By that time, the family’s financial situation got worsened. After graduation, I received a salary of 1,300 Baht or so. I rented a small room around a Bangkok’s area of Kiak Kai at 300 Baht per month. There were a bed and a small closet and that was it. Toilet was pool with other renters. I had to place my Buddha image on top of the closet, which was the highest location in the room. I lived like that until I obtained a government scholarship for a Master’s Degree. My family could no longer support me financially.

I was in love when I was between Year 1 to 2. Pojaman, who eventually became my beloved wife, and I started our relationship since then. A few years before my graduation, she went abroad for language study. I was tempted to come with her. At the time I was first in my police-cadet class and student leader. I chose police because no Shinawatra was in the police force before. We were present in the Army and the Air Force. Navy was never a choice for a boy from the mountainous north, since he was hardly a good swimmer. Now, this police-cadet scholar wanted to further his study in the US.

It was my desire to go to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). I got accepted. But the government salary of a scholar at $160 a month couldn’t allow it. I went instead to another institution. My mom gave another $1,000 of the family’s hard-earned money. As a young man, I had needs and wanted more money. Wanting a sporting car, Free Bird, I took an extra job at KFC, selling fried chicken. My senior Thai friends, Chidchai (Wannasathit, later a Ph.D., Drugs Suppression Chief, Deputy Police Commander, and Deputy Prime Minister) and Wichienchote (Sukchotirat, later a Ph.D., Deputy Permanent Secretary of the Justice Ministry and Government Spokesman) all worked. Chidchai was at UPS, doing the hard labor of loading boxes and all. Wichienchote waited tables at a hotel and he asked me to join him. I did. Eventually, I was also working in the hotel’s breakfast kitchen since I loved cooking. With little extra money, Pojaman soon joined me. We went out sometimes. My Master’s Degree took 1 year and 4 months to complete. It was longer than I should because I decided not to take summer courses but rather took a long drive around the US. Anyway, I was a straight A student. A in all courses.

I returned to Thailand alone because my love was still pursuing her degree. My rank was adjusted based on the new degree into Police Captain, with 1,800 Baht per month. Soon Pojaman came back and we were married. We had no home of our own. Not enough money for that. We then stayed with my wife’s parents until we decided that I should pursue my Ph.D. in the US. We returned to the US. I went to school. She didn’t. As fate would have it, I was away from Thailand at the times of our two major political riots: October 14 of 1973 and October 6, 1976. I only got news from here and there about what had happened. Even the May Incident of 1992, I was again out of the country.

The life of Bangkok Bank’s founder, the billionaire Chin Sophonpanich, inspired me to enrich myself in business. “If a person with only Grade 4 of educational background can do it,” I said to myself and my wife. “I as a Ph.D. pursuer must be able to earn some 100 million Baht in life”. We went to the US this time with that determination. Remember that my family, all 9 brothers and sisters, were all poor. My youngest sister Yinglak, currently AIS President, was only 9 years old. My father-in-law, who was then Commander of Bangkok Police’s Southern Area, contributed $100 a month for us. I combined it with $90, my police salary at home, and went off. My wife found a babysitting job for small children and a sales clerk at a department store. I studied hard, and also worked. My job was to fold newspaper and deliver them to home. Sometimes I missed out and had to recollect them. Some vicious dogs chased me with vengeance. Finally, a doctorate degree was obtained after 2 years and 8 months. My oldest son Oak was born in the US. When we carried him back with us, he was barely 5 months old.

We had 2 cars in the US: my left-steering wheel Mercedes Benz and my wife’s Volvo. The Volvo was sold as we wanted to keep the Mercedes. The problem was we couldn’t afford the tax. Our entire saving at the time was 200,000 Baht, but the tax was posted at 400,000 Baht. A loan was sought. We returned again to the home of my wife’s parents, who has 4 children. My wife and I was given a room. The others had to share. Every morning I went through every page of Bangkok Post’s Classified. I was so preoccupied with an extra income or more. I almost took a job as English instructor, somewhere in Nanglerng, and a job as Night Manager of a hotel. What choice did I have? No investment money. No network of friends in business. My wife’s family background was also governmental. No connection to business world, whatsoever. I built myself up one step at a time.

My family has had a silk business. We obtained some commodities without having to pay first. But we needed to open a shop. I joined a business group whose 5 members invested 10,000 Baht each. We took turn taking the whole sum of 50,000 Baht for business use. This was how I got started. I paid the rent to General Witoon Yasawat, who owned a hotel called Trocadero, where my rental shop was. My wife with our little boy baby went to the store everyday. Business was not good. We ended having boiled eggs for dinner everyday. Without the burden of payment for silk products, we were still in the red. I told my wife to mind the store and went out looking for other ways to survive.

Came another month, I found myself at a leading Thai film production company: Five Stars Promotion. My friend, Kiat Iampungporn, suggested that I purchased the right of his film to show at the cinema of the northern territory. The movie in question was one of the most popular ones: Ban Saithong (“The Saithong House”). The main female character was Pojaman, who bore my wife’s name. I thought of it as a good sign. Director Ruj Ronapop was also in support. So was Pracha Maleenont, Channel 3’s owner, whose friendship with me started there. We agreed. But the right fee was 1 million Baht, which I didn’t have. The Mercedes was put as a collateral so we had enough money to pay. Looking back, it was so risky.

The risk paid off. Within 1 month, we earned back one million Baht. The Mercedes returned to be ours. Another month was another 1.3 million, which was pure profit for me. It was the first time we touched upon that kind of sum. I went on to another film “Yod Talok” (“Super Funny”), played by Den Dokpradoo. This time, 300,000 Baht in profit. We went on to buy a house of our own. My wife asked to have a house in Chokechai 4, Ladprao, which belonged to my father-in-law. She got her wish. We then spent some money preparing the house and moved in for 6 years. This was where several businesses were conceived. My second baby girl was born here. With more success, we moved to a new house in Bangplad. Heard that a man came digging at the Ladprao house which was shut down. He claimed to get some dirt of a successful house to put among his own at a factory, so he too could be rich. Later, the movie business was in decline. Some were in red. My wife advised me to start a business which would rely on my own knowledge, instead of taking risks.

I was again in financial troubles. Bounced cheques started to appear. I became used to issuing pre-dated cheques. The middle man sold it at 5% interest rate. I was responsible for that. There were times I couldn’t even manage to pay the interest. They sued me. I went to court. Paying back and going to court in switching. I was sometimes close to put in jail. It was like drowning in a vast sea, but we managed to survive, barely so.

In Bangkok’s area of Rachawat, there was a movie house called “Dusit Theatre”. It was put out for sales. I wanted to own a piece of property. I went to “Maha Nakorn Trust” and asked for 18 million Baht (Actually, it was 18.5 million, but 500,000 Baht was spent on accommodation of the deal). I met the top person of the trust on Monday. He looked at me for a long time and granted it, at the interest rate of 21%. I asked him why he granted it. He said he mastered in the Chinese art of reading faces, and he found me never to go bankrupt on him. It was an old-fashioned way of doing business. I went along with it, too, but also with knowledge and information.

With the money, I owned several units of building there. Our plan was to sell 90 units for a big profit. Interest rate was so high and on my back all the time. I paid 325,000 Baht every month. Fridays were days of high pressure. Any Friday I talked the rate down to 300,000 Baht, it was a course for celebration. I packed up my family and we were off to Pataya. I needed a break to reduce my great tension. You must give yourself a break whenever you become too intense and stressful. You must sleep well. Closing eyes to rest and opening eyes to fight on. But the building construction hit a major roadblock. Interior Minister General Siddhi Jiraroj issued a ministerial order that all buildings near the royal palace must not exceed 21 metres in height. My 15 floors were reduced to 7 floors. A big chunk of profit went out the door. Even worse, the sales of buildings were eaten up by advertising cost. We decided to stop selling and bought back the sold units. My wife and I determined to go for a new direction, so our lives could stay afloat. She sought out 10 million Baht and handed it to me to embark on a new business: computer sales. It was Pojaman who asked me to march ahead with the business, and she would deal with the debts and financial problems it had caused.

That is the story for next time.

Tags: Thailand · Thaksin

20 responses so far ↓

  • 1 BangkokDan // Jan 28, 2010 at 6:50 pm

    Reads like a ghost-written autobiography … but who knows.

    “You must sleep well” – love that one.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 2 Patrick // Jan 28, 2010 at 9:13 pm

    This is actually a rough English-langauge script from a 74-minute online video rant:

    http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/4235122

    Not sure if anyone else cares, but check out minute 36:00 when he gets nostalgic for the 1973, two-door Pontiac Firebird he used to drive around. While working at KFC.

    Do you have to be American to get how hilarious that is? I love it. And I want photos of Meaw in the paper hat.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 3 polo // Jan 29, 2010 at 5:28 pm

    Patrick’s observation is just the beginning. Every time Thaksin suggests he was poor, he then says something that shows he was rich. It’s only a matter of whether he is deluding himself or that he thinks others would lap this up.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 4 Nganadeeleg // Jan 30, 2010 at 1:50 pm

    Agree with Polo – there seems to be some gaps in the story, particularly about his access to borrowed money.
    Sure the interest rate was high, but wouldn’t the bank manager need more security than just ambition?
    Running two cars also does not seem too much like a struggling students lifestyle to me.
    The other thing I found fascinating was the study for the police dept, with each degree leading to an automatic rank increase?
    I imagine there weould have to be some sort of bond or contract requiring him to remain in the dept – seems to have glossed over how he got out of the police into business – hopefully he will revisit that matter in Chapter 2.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 5 Suzie Wong // Jan 31, 2010 at 9:49 am

    Lacking of the contextual knowledge about traditional informal Chinese lending system in Thailand, American way of life, and the Thai government scholarship and bureaucratic promotional system, the comments made above are simply inaccurate.

    1. Informal lending system is still operating in Thailand similar to the lottery system. The coexisting of informal and formal systems, is common characteristics of most developing countries in transition towards a full market economy. Most of the informal money lending in Bangkok are operated by Thai Chinese. And as we know in a pre-modern society, fortune teller is still influential in Thais’ sets of belief. I think the lender did belief in the traditional Chinese face reading as well as intending to help another Thai Chinese by giving a hand to Thaksin to get his business started.

    2. In the Thai government scholarship system, if you study abroad one year you have to stay in the government for two years, the ratio of 1:2. And just like any other country, degree does count in the promotional decision. Most of Thais stay on with government jobs after the obligation period ended. However, some of the bright, talented and ambitious Thais would get out and take a risk with other type of jobs. Thaksin had made the choice to face the challenge of the business world and he succeeded.

    3. Having car in the U.S. is equivalent to having legs, with no meaning associate with luxurious life style. In the U.S. it is part of a daily life necessity. Unlike Europe and Asia where public transportation plays essential role, American way of life is based on freeway. American people use large car because it’s a very big country and the gasoline is inexpensive. Whereas European pay $90 to fill up a car, American would pay only $ 25. In the U.S. , it’s so easy to buy a car as long as you hold a job, you can buy a car with very low monthly payment of $200/month. An American two-door Pontiac Firebird is common and inexpensive in the oil rich Texas State. In the U.S. unless you drive Porsche, everything else is not big deal.

    I don’t think it’s fair to make comments without knowing the context. In the U.S., people would admire a self-made successful person like Thaksin, so does the present day China. In contrast to pre-modern Thai society, in developed as well as transition market economy, governments recognize the critical role of entrepreneurs as catalyst and the engine of growth and innovation.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 6 Nganadeeleg // Feb 1, 2010 at 11:51 am

    Thanks Suzie Wong for the providing the context – I was unaware that Thailand was such a land of opportunity (for those not too lazy to succeed:)

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 7 Suzie Wong // Feb 1, 2010 at 2:37 pm

    My basic thesis is that Thaksin has strived to make Siam to be “The Land of Opportunity”. By this, I mean socially, class mobility.

    It used to be the United States of America is the only land of opportunity. Now there are increasingly many other such lands in the world. It shows that there are opportunities everywhere and it depends on whether we are smart enough to spot them or to create opportunity for ourselves. Opportunity is useless unless you are willing to take advantage of it. Thaksin founded a successful computer company.

    Thaksin had stated that his goal in life was “The American Dream” so to speak, meaning to be wealthy like Chin Soponpanich the owner of the Bangkok Bank. If you understand Chinese cultural anthropology, this is a typical goal of people with Chinese root. Thaksin was diligent and persistent in his effort to achieve the goal he had set upon himself. He has the ability and will to get there. He was willing to work hard to achieve success. And with a little bit of luck, the willingness to walk through obstacles and tough competition, he succeeded. Success at that magnitude never happened by chance.

    After being successful, he wants to make that dream possible for other Thais. With his experience living in the U.S. , Thaksin has strived to make Siam to be what America was created to be — equality of opportunity is the fundamental principle by which America was founded. This is the principal factor why Thaksin has strong grass root support throughout the country.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 8 StanG // Feb 1, 2010 at 3:22 pm

    This story is written for the foreigners, I suspect Thais don’t see anything unusual or spectacular in his progress. In those days success was everywhere, everybody was moving up and up and up, everybody was cashing in on decades of 10% a year growth.

    It might be more difficult now, but, on the other hand, Thai working culture is more open to meritocracy than in those days. Chances for upward mobility are still there.

    Also, shouldn’t we play a bit of “spot the difference” between this autobiography and Baker/Pasuk’s version of Thaksin’s rise?

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 9 Patrick // Feb 1, 2010 at 4:09 pm

    @ Stan: I see where you’re coming from, but check the link above — this is just the English-language transcript of a 74-minute online video in Thai.

    The (rough) English transcript was e-mailed by a red shirt organizer to foreign press, farang academics, etc. The tale itself, however, is mostly meant for Thais.

    As for Thais sensing truth in his tale, agreed – I think that’s the point of this video.

    The timing of this tale coincides with Thaksin’s assets ruling — and I think he wants to detail his ascent to wealth to prove that he isn’t suspiciously rich.

    It’s easy to admire how many business flops and dead ends this guy swallowed before he climbed to the top. Count his ventures: cop, silk trading, film producing, telecoms, politician, etc. You gotta respect his hustle.

    Whether Thaksin acted like a jackass once he reached the top, however, is up for debate.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 10 Hla Oo // Feb 1, 2010 at 4:31 pm

    Correct me if I am wrong, Ms Susie Wong!

    Police officer Dr. Thaksin Shinawatra made his first serious money by introducing and selling the personal computers wholesale to the Thai Police Force when his father-in-law was a high ranking officer.

    His family company was granted a computer monopoly by the Thai Police and also some other government agencies, and he milked the contracts so good the business made him a Thai billionaire. Then was the time an IBM PC could easily cost 10,000 US$ in Bangkok and a Taiwanese clone was at about half that price.

    No need to mention his later satellite communication business which made him much, much richer. It was also a monopoly too. I don’t think he is a champion of the people by the people and for the people!

    He is just a pseudo-industrialist who sees his opportunities and knows how to grab them quick with the help of some ruling-class insiders!

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 11 polo // Feb 1, 2010 at 4:52 pm

    Suzie Wong: some of what you say might be true now, but not back when Thaksin studied. Only the very richest kids at my university — the most spoiled jerks — had Firebirds, and many did not have cars. Most considered the cost of gas significant. Most did not have family members in high political positions who could get them licenses and contracts without having to compete. …. Oops,that part was not in his biography!

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 12 chris beale // Feb 2, 2010 at 1:22 am

    I have n’t seen anyone mention that Thaksin eventually made his first fortune due to Thailand’s massively over-protected economy, its’ lack of an economic rationalist level capitalist playing field :
    Thaksin won the exclusive right to supply computers to his own police department – without an open tender, if my memory serves me well of what Baker, Pasuk and others have written.
    In other words : typical Thai rentier capitalism/ semi-fuedalism.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 13 BKK Lawyer // Feb 2, 2010 at 4:30 am

    StanG: You say “Thai working culture is more open to meritocracy than in those days.” A nice thought, seemingly innocuous. But contrary to everything we usually hear about Thai society.

    You implicitly acknowledge that the Thai working culture previously was not open to meritocracy. Of course, Thai history is full of examples. When did this change, and what caused it?

    I know few Thais who respect merit over the traditional “values” of wealth, seniority, the “right” ethnicity, etc. I hear of few such Thais in the news, even Thais in academia. I personally know Thais who have studied and received a quality education abroad and come home to be sent to the back row because they don’t come from the right family.

    So again, pray, tell us when, where and why has Thai working culture now come to embrace this Western value of meritocracy?

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 14 EURUSDTrader // Feb 2, 2010 at 8:14 am

    BKKLawyer: I would love to see an article specifically on this topic. I *hear* about meritocracy in Thailand, but I’ve certainly never witnessed it. I see Thailand as having an informal caste system that is SO informal that most Thais don’t even perceive or acknowledge it. Of course if you are a foreigner with the “correct” traits you can use these cultural biases to your advantage;-) Outward markers of social class can get you a VERY long way in Bangkok if you are prepared to play that game.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 15 BKK Lawyer // Feb 2, 2010 at 6:44 pm

    EURUSDTrader: Good points.

    We all know there are many Thais who go abroad for Western education. They yearn for it. Their families yearn for it. So I always assumed their Western educations are highly valued by their fellow Thais when they return to Thailand to put their knowledge to work.

    So I was shocked recently to hear a friend describe numerous Thai friends of his who have returned to the Thai workplace with a Western education and are simply shunned by their Thai colleagues, who fear losing face to someone with a superior education.

    I was also shocked to meet a Thai dentist who received his degree in Thailand and went to study further in the U.S., and returned to Thailand to continue his post-grad education in dentistry, but he could not gain admission to the program (at Chula) because, although he was clearly qualified, the program was very limited in size and was already filled by students from “the right families.”

    These are only anecdotes, of course. I would also like to see a report on this topic, with a rigorous survey. Thailand appears to be progressing by sending its best students abroad for education and training, but if Thais are in actuality shunning those people when they return BECAUSE of their superior knowledge, that is distressing.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 16 StanG // Feb 2, 2010 at 7:16 pm

    I don’t have any studies to back it up, but consider this – growth of the economy far outpaces growth of the “elites”. There aren’t enough “connected” people to run everything in the country. Not to mention fierce competition in the market.

    From what I know about headhunting business, the demand for capable and experienced personnel is very very high.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 17 tukkae // Feb 3, 2010 at 3:40 am

    Now Part 2 went online on his homepage.

    Awful transmission quality and hardly understandable.

    Stan, I can assure you it is definitely in Thai and designated for the Thai audience. He talks lenghty about how he was bored with Analogue Transmission Technology and decided to get into digital mobile business.

    Lesson to learn from it – a few decades later – he should urgently do some technical improvements to his homepage…

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 18 AP // Mar 20, 2010 at 2:42 pm

    I believe everyone has already dissected the story and provided their valued thoughts, but here is my bob’s worth.

    Childhood:

    A business family selling clothes and coffee, and children going to school have better chances to eat food and will be considered rich as compared to people working in farm and barely had some food to eat once per day. This is still relevant in present days of Thai life. Thaksin is around 57/58 years old now which means he was 3-4 years old in 1956/57. Owning a motorcycle at that time was a big deal, 80 baht meant a huge amount and only rich person could spare 400 baht for toys. As he mentioned, they owned the only refrigerator in whole area.

    Student Life

    He must have been smart to make it this far as a rich man, however, getting a scholarship to study in US either needs knowing high profile people or paying huge sums of money as bribe. It is unclear that which option was used. Although his then girl friend – Pojaman hailed from an affluent family and whose father was a high profile police officer. Go figure.

    I know that students take time off or gap period during studies for travel. But, a cash strapped student taking a 4 months driving holiday may be hard to swallow.

    Student Load and exit from police

    Every student who studies on government’s scholarship has to work for the duration specified in bond (as in previous comments ratio could 1:2), as well as need to pay back student loan for amount spent during studies. How did Thaksin paid it back before his Phd? It is unclear as well. It is also not evident if he quit police job before pursuing Phd as he said that he contributed his father-in-law’s money with police salary.

    PHD

    My poor man worked very hard during his time in the US, but still managed to buy a Benz and a Volvo. We are talking roughly around mid-70s. If someone could afford such cars at that time, then he/she was definitely not poor.

    Business life

    There is no doubt that he was an opportunistic business man. Be it using contacts to win contracts, or exploiting system to provide rights to his companies, he took every opportunity to expand his business, and most of the business men would have done the same. And, in the end thats what it boils down to.

    On a separate note, why a business man who made a fortune and then found guilty is so important? It is because, he is exploiting people for his own purpose. Red t-shirt supporters are going around in Bangkok on rallies for his support. I support this movement too as long as they stay away from Thaksin and his agendas. Yes, there should be open elections and the loser should become effective opposition to govern ruling party. That is democracy and I as a person support it. But, Thaksin should stay away from this movement and people should stay away from him for the purpose of these rallies.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 19 michael // Mar 20, 2010 at 8:31 pm

    Excellent post, AP #18. I thoroughly agree with it, including “I support this movement too as long as they stay away from Thaksin and his agendas. Yes, there should be open elections and the loser should become effective opposition to govern ruling party. That is democracy and I as a person support it. But, Thaksin should stay away from this movement and people should stay away from him for the purpose of these rallies.”

    And also, let’s hope that the army, the police, and the public service learn their place as well. (I’m not stupid enough to believe that this will happen quickly.) BTW, in an interview with BBC last night, the PM stated that he was living in a military barracks for the duration because he didn’t want to be responsible for the government killing its own people yet again (paraphrasal only). An admirable statement, if we take it at face value…Comments?

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • 20 AP // Mar 21, 2010 at 1:09 am

    Michael. You are right that progress and liberation comes when whole country works as a well lubricated engine and every component knows it place. It will take time for any country that has such legacy baggage as Thailand as 14-16 years are not enough to bed down democratic system and thoughts in minds of people contributing to this system.

    As far as comments on Abhisit’s statements are concerned. I would not trust, admire or react to a politician’s statement on it’s face value. As a person he is a scholar and has charismatic personality, he could not prove to be an effective opposition in past and seems to be just a figure in whole puppet show. So, his comments do not count for me. However, I do agree with his recent comments asking Thaksin to stop starting “Class war” and divide the nation. A common ground needs to be achieved soon otherwise it could be danger to this country’s solidarity.

    I think at the moment the country needs someone whom the whole country listens to. Correct me if I am wrong, but I only know 1 person whom people love and respect like this and his intervention for a mediation could save a lot of trouble. But then again, it would not be right for democratic movement.

    Quality comment or not? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Comment

Please note: New Mandala encourages vigorous debate. However, for the moment we will only be publishing high-quality comments that make original contributions to discussion. There will, of course, still be space for pithy, humorous, eccentric and cheeky input. Short and sweet will usually trump long and involved. Repetitive ranting, unimaginative point-scoring and idle abuse will not be entertained. Comments which carry a real name are also more likely to be approved. Thank you for your ongoing interest and contributions.

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>